Duke & The Movies

Film Criticism


Model videochat in Bucuresti Studio Videochat

videochat studio in Bucuresti Videochat

Written by: Sam Fragoso on January 12, 2012

January 12, 2012 | 12 comments | Featured, Old Format

Joyful Noise

The inner cynic in myself wants to dismantle Joyful Noise for its sheer lack of authenticity and originality.

But there’s a heart to Todd Graff’s third directorial effort that I can’t quite shake.

Set in present day, the film follows a small-town choir group dedicated to finally (after consistently coming up short) winning the National competition.

Though, the high-pressured competition is merely a plot vehicle driven by the characters on screen.

Olivia Hill (Keke Palmer) is the elegant and soulful 16-year-old girl who doesn’t have a life outside of choir and school, due to her overbearing mother Vi Rose (Queen Latifah). The father apparently “abandoned” the family a couple years ago to head for the army, in order to “pay the bills”. And then there’s Walter, their son who has an illness that  forces him to speak excessively and act primarily off uncontrollable internal impulses.

Again, the melodramatic family moments are just another distraction to segway into the films main purpose: the music.

The choir is composed of local, goody-goody folk. It’s that persona that they’ve adopted that’s ultimately been keeping them back from obtaining that championship.

Thankfully the groups lack of creativity is supplied in spades by the new kid in town: Randy Garrity (Jeremy Jordan) a wise-cracking, smart ass 20 something whose Grandmother – G.G. Sparrow (Dolly Patton making her triumphant return to film) is the founder of the Church and choir.

As with any farcical device, a romantic relationship is formed between Olivia and Randy. And of course Olivia’s controlling mother doesn’t approve and vows to keep the two separated. And of course G.G. – being the free loving woman she is – shares different beliefs with how their relationship should be overseen. And of course this dissolves into a catfight between the two older women, duking it out in a middling restaraunt, and throwing stale roles and hot spaghetti at one another.

I say of course, because, well, this by now is to be expected from a film like Joyful Noise: a chummy, slight, and crowd-pleasing affair that’s more forgettable than anything.

Dolly Parton and Queen Latifah bickering in "Joyful Noise". What comes after the bicker is a cat fight till the death. Or at least until one is sufficiently hurt. Either or.

While the film continues the choir group rebuilds and reforms beginning to embark on a nuanced journey of gospel music. This is the year that they’re finally going to bounce back and make their mark in the winning circle.

The characters aren’t nearly as interesting as the music they’re singing. A culmination of contemporary hits and timeless classics circulate the atmosphere of Joyful Noise. Songs ranging from Michael Jackson’s Man In The Mirror to Paul McCartney’s Maybe I’m Amazed – are sung by the ambiguous choir group. They’re destined for change. Unfortunately – their leader – Vi Rose, isn’t. She believes in staying faithful to the Lords antiqued hymns.

But le be hold, she’ll be there when the finale comes around. Which – may I add – is the revelation of the film.

In a concluding set piece that’s completed with absolute, soulful passion – Graff morphs the rhythms and beats from a Sly and the Family Stone’s jam, sex-driven rap by Usher, and Motown perfection by Stevie Wonder – into one, coherent piece of inspirational music.

Surely Joyful Noise is nowhere near the quality of its music sequences. And if I am to be candid, it’s a mediocre piece of cinema – driven merely by caricatures and an unbelievably hokey narrative.

But for those who want to feel good, the film just about does its job. It doesn’t reinvent the wheel of musicals – nor does it put a dent of shame into the already lackluster genre.

Albeit that I’ll likely forget about the film by the time this article is published, Joyful Noise – while it lasts - is pure, unadulturated fun.

Rating: ★★☆☆

Joyful Noise

Joyful Noise (2012)

Cast: Dolly Parton, Queen Latifah, Keke Palmer

Director: Todd Graff

Writer: Todd Graff

Runtime: n/a

Genre: music, comedy

Trailer Joyful Noise


There are 12 comments for this post.

  1. Candice Frederick on January 12, 2012 4:49 pm

    ugh. i’m not into the feel good movies, but your review sounds appealing.

  2. Duke on January 12, 2012 9:09 pm

    Thank you for reading Candice. It has its moments. If you enjoy musicals, it’s for you.

  3. Scott Lawlor on January 12, 2012 10:56 pm

    This is a film that I would probably avoid like the plague. Thanks for reviewing it Sam and giving me an insight to it though.


  4. Duke on January 12, 2012 11:31 pm

    It’s not that bad Scott! Perfectly acceptable for those who love the genre.

  5. Matt Stewart on January 13, 2012 11:09 am

    I honestly am in Scott’s boat, I like musicals but I KNOW I won’t like this. Still, I have heard some good things about it.

    Fine review Sam!

  6. Duke on January 13, 2012 11:10 am

    Thanks Matt! Glad you enjoy musicals at the least.

  7. NeverTooEarlyMP on January 13, 2012 3:45 pm

    Nice review! I can see this one being fun in a way, but probably won’t catch it in theaters given the time of year it is. Feels more like a summer comedy to me.

  8. Duke on January 13, 2012 4:31 pm

    This could certainly work as a summer, light comedy.

  9. Alex Withrow on January 16, 2012 7:35 am

    Hmm, what a fair and balanced review. Credit earned where credit is due. Still, I doubt I’ll be seeing it. Unless I’m on a flight and there’s nothing else on. Then… maybe.

  10. Duke on January 16, 2012 7:55 pm

    Lets be honest … you’ll never see this ;)

  11. Bucky Larson: Born to be a Star (2011) « Can't Stop the Movies | Four Friends Vs. Film on January 18, 2012 5:00 am

    [...] an average moviegoer spots, which is fine, but I started to second guess my opinion further when other reviewers took a soft spot to it.  This isn’t to say they liked it, but it became clear that [...]

  12. LAMBScores: The Iron Lady, Contraband, A Separation and Joyful Noise | | Beth Stollman BlogBeth Stollman Blog on February 10, 2012 2:27 pm

    [...] Duke & The Movies [...]

Write a Comment